|
Top : Movie Reviews : Episode I - The Phantom Menace
- Bob Graham - San Francisco Chronicle
- Bob Graham draws the popular conclusion that Lucas' first effort to rekindle the Star Wars legacy through this new trilogy is thick on brilliant special effects enhancements and thin on the sort of character development that fans of the original trilogy have come to crave.
(Added: 3-Apr-2005 Hits: 1511 Rating: 10.00 Votes: 1) Rate It
- David Edelstein - Slate
- Edelstein, like many critics, finds The Phantom Menace a visual spectacle, but one that fails to ignite the imagination.
(Added: 3-Apr-2005 Hits: 1449 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
- Roger Ebert - Chicago Sun Times
- Ever the Star Wars fan, Roger Ebert's review of Episode I oozes the type of enthusiasm and joi-de-vivre that dominated discussion of the original trilogy. He basks in the wonderous cityscapes, entertaining characterisations and simple storyline enough to forgive some of the weaknesses that so dogged other critics' perceptions of the film.
(Added: 3-Apr-2005 Hits: 1330 Rating: 5.00 Votes: 1) Rate It
- The Lonesome Road Staff
- Providing a little balance against the majority opinion of critics at the time of Episode I's release, the four reviews presented here all reflect positive Phantom Menace experiences.
(Added: 3-Apr-2005 Hits: 1520 Rating: 0 Votes: 0) Rate It
Submit your Star Wars-related website to the directory for free!
|
